Compare your offers
Type in each lender's Loan Estimate. The numbers below are samples until you change them.
Estimates from the numbers typed here. Your Loan Estimate's page 3 shows the official APR, which also counts a few charges this page does not.
How to shop for a loan
Five steps, about one week.
- Talk to three lenders in the same week
Try a mix: a bank or credit union, a mortgage broker and an online lender. Credit checks for a mortgage made within a short window (14 to 45 days, depending on the scoring model) count as one check, so shopping does not hurt your score more than one would.
- Ask each one for a Loan Estimate on the same day
Rates change every day. Give every lender the same price, down payment, loan type and lock length, or the offers are not comparable. A lender must send the Loan Estimate within three business days of your application, and can only charge for a credit report before it does.
- Line up page 2, section A
"Origination charges" are the lender's own fees, the part you are really shopping. Once your rate is locked, they cannot go up at closing unless something about your loan changes. Title, appraisal and taxes are mostly the same whoever lends.
- Compare total cost, not just the rate or the APR
Put each offer in the comparison above. What matters is what you pay over the years you will actually keep the loan.
- Ask the others to beat the best offer, then lock
Show the cheapest Loan Estimate to the lender you would rather use and ask them to match it. Once you choose, lock the rate long enough to cover your closing date.
Rate, APR, points and fees
What each number on the offer means.
Sets your monthly payment. It does not include any fees.
Money paid at closing to get a lower rate. One point is 1% of the loan: on $400,000, one point is $4,000. Worth it only if you keep the loan past the break-even.
Origination, underwriting, processing: the lender's own charges, on page 2, section A. These vary the most between lenders and are often negotiable.
The opposite of points: the lender pays some of your closing costs and you take a higher rate. Good when you expect to sell or refinance soon.
The rate plus points and lender fees, spread over the full loan term. It is the best single number for comparing, but it assumes you keep the loan all 30 years. If you will sell or refinance sooner, a loan with points looks better on APR than it really is.
What you pay the lender over the years you keep the loan: points and fees, minus credits, plus the interest. This is what the comparison ranks.
Buydowns
Points. You pay at closing and the rate is lower for the whole loan. Use the comparison above to see when the points pay back.
The payment is lower for the first year or few, then goes to the full rate. The 2-1 is the most common: 2 points under the rate in year one, 1 point under in year two, then the full rate. A 1-0 lowers year one only; a 3-2-1 runs three years. The cost goes into an account at closing that tops up each payment.
Often the seller, as a credit you negotiate in the offer, or a builder on a new home. Your loan type caps how much the seller can pay, often 3% to 6% of the price for most buyers, so ask your lender for the limit on your loan. Most lenders still qualify you at the full rate.
A seller credit put toward points lowers the rate for good; the same money as a temporary buydown lowers only the first years. A temporary buydown helps most when you want a smaller payment while you settle in, or expect to refinance if rates drop.
What a temporary buydown looks like on your loan
Junk fees and how to negotiate
Origination (often around 0.5% to 1% of the loan), the appraisal, the credit report, and title and escrow fees. Government charges like recording fees and transfer taxes are set by the county or state, not the lender.
Processing, application, administration, document preparation, rate-lock and "courier" or "e-document" fees on top of an origination charge. Several small fees that do the same job are where lenders add margin. These are the first ones to ask about.
Page 2, section C lists services you can shop for: title, survey, pest inspection. The lender gives a list of providers, but you can pick your own and compare prices.
How to negotiate
- Have competing offers in hand
Two or three Loan Estimates from the same day are your leverage. Without them, a lender has no reason to move.
- Ask about the total, then the lines
"Another lender's section A is $X lower. Can you match it?" Then name each padding fee and ask to remove it.
- Ask for a credit, not just a lower rate
A lender that will not cut a fee will often give a credit at closing for the same amount.
- Ask your agent to negotiate with the seller
A seller credit can pay closing costs, points or a buydown. Your agent asks for it in the offer.
- Get every change on a revised Loan Estimate
A promise on the phone is not a price. Once your rate is locked, lender charges in section A cannot go up at closing unless your loan changes, so the revised Loan Estimate protects you.
Questions to ask your lender
Ask every lender the same ones. Tick them off as you go; the ticks stay on this device.
In the Informi app, read a Loan Estimate straight into an offer, check every fee line in LE Audit, and keep your comparison with your home search.