A Restaurant's Unpaid 2023 Rent Could Change How Landlords Count to One Year
California Apartment Association says it has asked the state Supreme Court to step in on Universal Shopping Plaza v. Hong, an appellate ruling that blurs how long a landlord has to serve a three-day notice to pay rent or quit. That notice is the written demand a landlord serves when rent is unpaid: pay up or leave within three days. State law says it must be served within one year.
Here is the case. A San Gabriel restaurant operator held back $65,989 in early 2023, claiming a discount the landlord disputed. He then paid the equivalent of monthly rent for about two years. The lease said payments go to the oldest debt first, and the trial court sided with the landlord on that basis. The appeals court reversed, treating the demand as one for the 2023 money and calling it too late.
My read: the ruling suggests the day a tenant first fell short can outweigh what your lease says about where payments land. CAA argues you should first work out what each payment covered, then apply the one-year limit to whatever remains. The case is commercial, but the statutes also govern residential nonpayment, and the opinion isn't limited to commercial leases.
If you work with landlords, the patient one is the exposed one. Letting a tenant catch up could now cost that landlord leverage. CAA warns that owners may file earlier and skip repayment talks, which means more court time and cost. I'd tell any client to call their attorney before accepting partial payments on an old balance. Take notice of the notice, because the clock doesn't care how nice you were.
CAA also asked, as a backup, for depublication, which would leave the parties' result alone but strip the opinion of precedent.
Post this
Paste into a social post, a newsletter or a client text. Every line is from the record above, and the link brings your audience back here.
A Restaurant's Unpaid 2023 Rent Could Change How Landlords Count to One Year https://informi.app/news/w/a-restaurant-s-unpaid-2023-rent-could-change-how-landlords-count-to-on-22af1326 Reported by CA Apartment Association.
California Apartment Association says it has asked the state Supreme Court to step in on Universal Shopping Plaza v. Hong, an appellate ruling that blurs how long a landlord has to serve a three-day notice to pay rent or quit. That notice is the written demand a landlord serves when rent is unpaid: https://informi.app/news/w/a-restaurant-s-unpaid-2023-rent-could-change-how-landlords-count-to-on-22af1326 Reported by CA Apartment Association.
Open this in Content Studio → Agents — edits, saves and schedules alongside your other posts.